Renting a car is one of the most practical ways to explore Long Island, New York — especially for travelers who want to see beyond the main train lines and access the beaches, vineyards, and historic towns that define the region. With scenic drives, upscale destinations, and limited public transport in many areas, having your own vehicle can make your trip far more enjoyable.
This detailed guide covers everything independent travelers need to know about renting a car in Long Island — from top rental companies to local regulations and insider travel tips.
Some links in this post may be affiliate links — I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Is It Worth Renting a Car in Long Island?
For many travelers, the answer is yes — especially if you plan to explore more than one part of Long Island.
Why travelers rent cars here:
- Long Island covers over 100 miles from Queens to Montauk — ideal for scenic road trips.
- Public transport is limited outside the LIRR (Long Island Rail Road) and doesn’t serve beach towns, vineyards, or small historic villages well.
- Renting a car is helpful for beach hopping, visiting wineries, and accessing areas like the Hamptons, Fire Island ferry terminals, or North Fork farms.
Advantages of renting a car:
- Flexibility to explore the island’s scenic coastlines, historic sites, and rural escapes.
- Convenient for families or groups traveling together.
- Faster travel times and easier luggage transport.
Limitations of public transport:
- The LIRR mainly connects to New York City and a few central hubs — not ideal for beach towns or rural stops.
- Buses are available but can be infrequent and slow.
- Rideshares like Uber and Lyft are available but may be expensive for long-distance travel.
If you’re planning to visit multiple towns, take day trips, or explore eastern Long Island, renting a car is highly recommended.
Where to Rent a Car in Long Island
Long Island offers many convenient rental locations — whether you’re arriving by train, ferry, or plane.
Popular rental locations:
- Airports:
- Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) in Islip has several national rental brands.
- JFK and LaGuardia Airports in nearby Queens also serve Long Island travelers.
- Train stations:
Many LIRR stops like Hicksville, Huntington, and Ronkonkoma have nearby car rental offices. - Downtown locations:
Offices in towns like Garden City, Riverhead, and Patchogue offer rentals for local travelers or weekend visitors. - Ferry terminals:
Some rental locations are available near ferry ports to Fire Island or Connecticut (via Port Jefferson or Orient Point).
Trusted national brands available:
- Enterprise – Widely available, good for local pickups and flexible returns.
- Hertz – Offers luxury and exotic car rentals.
- Avis/Budget – Budget-friendly with convenient locations near transit hubs.
- SIXT – Known for upscale vehicle options.
Local agencies:
- All Island Car Rentals – Serving areas like Patchogue and Holbrook.
- Executive Car Rental – Offers exotic and high-end vehicles.
- Long Island Exotic Cars – Specializes in premium, sports, and luxury vehicles for special occasions or high-end trips.
Typical operating hours:
Most offices are open 7:30 AM to 6:00 PM, with airport locations offering extended hours or 24/7 drop-offs.
Compare rental options here to find the best vehicle and pickup location for your trip.
Recommended Car Rental Companies in Long Island
Choosing the right rental company depends on your travel style, budget, and location. Here are some reliable options to consider:
- Enterprise Rent-A-Car
Pros: Excellent customer service, many neighborhood locations, flexible rentals.
Cons: Limited exotic/luxury vehicle options. - Hertz
Pros: Large fleet with luxury models, good airport service.
Cons: Premium vehicles can be pricey in peak season. - SIXT
Pros: Stylish, European-inspired vehicles; competitive pricing on upscale models.
Cons: Fewer suburban locations compared to Enterprise. - Avis/Budget
Pros: Affordable prices, good for compact or economy cars.
Cons: May have fewer specialty vehicles available.
Search and compare trusted car rental companies here to find what suits your needs and budget.
How Much Does It Cost to Rent a Car in Long Island
Rental costs vary depending on the season, vehicle type, and location. Here’s a general overview:
Average daily rental rates:
- Compact/Economy cars: $45–$65 per day
- Mid-size/SUVs: $60–$90 per day
- Luxury/Exotic vehicles: $150–$300+ per day (depending on availability and season)
Key pricing factors:
- Seasonality: Rates rise during summer and holiday weekends, especially in the Hamptons and beach areas.
- Insurance: Adding optional coverage can increase daily rates by $10–$30.
- Mileage: Most rentals offer unlimited mileage, but confirm this when booking.
- One-way rentals: May include a drop-off fee if returning to a different location.
- Age fees: Drivers under 25 may pay an additional daily fee (usually $25–$35).
Check live prices here for real-time rates and availability based on your dates.
Requirements for Renting a Car in Long Island
Before booking, make sure you meet the rental company’s basic requirements:
- Minimum age:
Most agencies require renters to be at least 21 years old. Drivers under 25 may be limited to certain vehicle types and subject to a surcharge. - Driver’s license:
A valid U.S. driver’s license is required. International visitors need a passport and a valid license in English or an International Driving Permit (IDP). - Credit/Debit cards:
- Credit cards are widely accepted and usually required for security deposits.
- Debit cards may be accepted with additional documentation, especially for non-airport rentals.
- Insurance coverage:
- Basic liability coverage is often included by law.
- Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW) can be added or waived if covered by your credit card or travel insurance.
Best Time to Rent a Car in Long Island
Rental prices and availability in Long Island can change dramatically throughout the year.
Seasonal demand:
- High season: Late spring through early fall, especially Memorial Day to Labor Day.
- Off-season: Winter months (excluding holidays) tend to offer better deals and more vehicle options.
Why book early:
- Popular car types, especially SUVs and luxury models, sell out quickly in summer.
- Booking at least 2–4 weeks in advance often ensures lower rates and better selection.
Weather considerations:
- Long Island’s summer is ideal for convertible or beach-friendly vehicles.
- In winter, consider an SUV with good traction for possible icy conditions.
Driving Tips in Long Island and Surroundings
Driving in Long Island is generally smooth and straightforward, especially if you’re familiar with U.S. traffic rules. However, there are a few local tips that can make your experience safer and more convenient.
Road conditions and navigation:
- Major roads like the Long Island Expressway (I-495), Northern State Parkway, and Sunrise Highway are well maintained but can get congested during rush hours.
- GPS or smartphone apps like Google Maps or Waze are highly recommended for avoiding traffic and navigating smaller towns and back roads.
- Roundabouts are common in areas like the Hamptons—slow down and yield properly.
Wildlife safety tips:
- While Long Island doesn’t have moose, deer crossings are common, particularly in the eastern parts like Suffolk County and wooded areas near Montauk.
- Be especially alert when driving at dawn, dusk, or in rural zones.
Fuel station availability:
- Gas stations are plentiful throughout Long Island, including along highways and in suburban areas.
- Some remote areas near beaches or parks may have fewer options, so fill up before longer drives.
Parking tips:
- Downtown areas (e.g., Huntington, Patchogue, or Port Jefferson) often have metered parking. Use local apps like ParkMobile to pay.
- Beach parking usually requires a seasonal permit for residents, but non-resident day passes are often available for a fee.
- Train stations and shopping centers generally offer free or low-cost parking, but overnight parking may be restricted.
For updated traffic reports and road alerts, visit the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) or your local town’s visitor bureau site.
Alternatives to Renting a Car in Long Island
Depending on your travel style and where you’re staying, you may not always need a rental car for your entire trip.
Rail service:
- The Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) is a reliable option for travel between New York City and major Long Island hubs like Hicksville, Babylon, and Montauk.
- It’s best for point-to-point travel, but not ideal for accessing beaches, wineries, or small towns.
Shuttles, taxis, and rideshares:
- Airport and hotel shuttle services are available in major towns and at MacArthur Airport.
- Uber and Lyft are widely used but may have limited availability in rural areas or during off-peak times.
- Taxis can be found at train stations and airports but usually need to be called in advance outside urban areas.
Walking and biking:
- Town centers like Greenport, Port Jefferson, and Huntington Village are pedestrian-friendly.
- Some towns offer bike rentals, especially in beach areas during summer.
When you may not need a rental car:
- If you’re only visiting one town with walkable attractions and staying centrally.
- If you’re attending a wedding or event where transport is provided.
- If you’re using the LIRR for a direct trip from NYC with no plans to explore further.
Still unsure? Compare rental options here to see if having your own car would improve your itinerary.
Best Road Trips from Long Island
Long Island offers excellent opportunities for scenic drives, coastal exploration, and countryside escapes. Here are some favorite road trip ideas:
- The Hamptons and Montauk Point (2–3 hours): Drive through luxury estates, art galleries, lighthouses, and beaches.
- North Fork Wine Trail (1–2 hours): Explore vineyards, farm stands, and waterfront restaurants along Route 25.
- Fire Island Ferry Launches (45–90 mins): Drive to ferry terminals in Bay Shore, Sayville, or Patchogue, then explore the car-free barrier island.
- Gold Coast Mansions (1–1.5 hours): Visit historic estates like Oheka Castle and Old Westbury Gardens.
- Shelter Island (via ferry): A quiet getaway accessible by ferry from Greenport or North Haven.
Each route offers a unique look into Long Island’s coastal beauty and historical charm — made even better with the flexibility of your own vehicle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, a rental car is highly recommended. Public transport options like the LIRR can take you partway, but you’ll need a car to explore beaches, restaurants, and different towns within the Hamptons.
MacArthur Airport (ISP) is the most convenient option for car rentals directly on Long Island. You can also fly into JFK or LaGuardia, rent a car there, and drive east, though traffic from NYC can be heavy.
Yes. Companies like Hertz Dream Cars, SIXT, and local agencies such as Long Island Exotic Cars offer luxury vehicles including convertibles, sports cars, and premium SUVs.
Check availability of luxury car rentals here.
It depends on the area. Suburban towns and shopping centers typically have ample parking. However, beach areas and village centers may require paid parking or permits, especially in summer.
There are no major toll roads within Long Island itself, but if you’re driving from NYC, you may encounter tolls on bridges and tunnels. Use E-ZPass or ask your rental company if it’s included.
Yes. Most rental companies accept foreign driver’s licenses (if in English) or require an International Driving Permit (IDP). A valid passport and credit card are also required.
Most companies require renters to be 21 or older, with underage surcharges applying to drivers under 25. Luxury or specialty vehicles may require drivers to be at least 25.
You can bring a rental car to Shelter Island via ferry, but Fire Island is mostly car-free, and bringing vehicles is not allowed or practical for most visitors. Park nearby and take a pedestrian ferry instead.
During summer and holiday weekends, it’s best to book 2–4 weeks in advance, especially for SUVs or luxury vehicles, which tend to sell out quickly.
Final Tips Before You Book
To get the most out of your Long Island car rental:
- Book early to secure the best rates and vehicle availability during busy travel seasons.
- Inspect the vehicle before leaving the lot. Check for dents, scratches, fuel level, and tire condition.
- Understand the terms regarding mileage, fuel policy, tolls, and late return fees.
- Bring your paperwork including driver’s license, credit card, and insurance documents, if applicable.
Ready to explore Long Island? Compare trusted car rental options here to find the perfect vehicle for your trip.
Leon A. LuisLeon A. Luis holds a degree in Economics but has always been driven by an insatiable love of travel. A dedicated solo traveler with a special fondness for road trips, kayaking adventures, and long, contemplative train journeys, Leon believes the best way to understand the world is to move through it slowly and deliberately. As a passionate travel writer, he’s committed to sharing detailed, practical advice and personal insights to help readers plan unforgettable journeys of their own. At traveleon.com, Leon focuses on car rental tips, transport guides, and all the essential details travelers need to navigate new places confidently. When he’s not exploring backroads or paddling quiet waterways, he’s working on plans to author books about the art and joy of road-tripping.