Car Rental in Block Island 2025

Planning a trip to Block Island? While this small island off the coast of Rhode Island is known for its charming coastal views and relaxing pace, having a car can make your visit smoother and more flexible—especially if you’re short on time or want to explore more than just downtown. This guide offers a complete overview of renting a car in Block Island, with practical tips, estimated costs, and trusted rental options.

Some links in this post may be affiliate links — I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

---

Is It Worth Renting a Car in Block Island?

For many travelers, yes—renting a car on Block Island is worth it. While it’s only about 10 square miles in size, public transportation options are limited, and walking or biking everywhere isn’t always ideal, especially if you want to reach multiple beaches or visit less-touristy spots like the North Lighthouse or Rodman’s Hollow.

Here are a few reasons why renting a car might make sense:

• Flexibility to explore remote areas like Mohegan Bluffs or Mansion Beach.
• Convenience when traveling with luggage or beach gear.
• Time efficiency—especially helpful for day-trippers or short stays.
• Comfort during colder or rainy months, when biking or walking is less practical.

However, if you’re planning to stay in town and stick to one or two attractions, alternatives like bikes, mopeds, or taxis might be enough.

---

Where to Rent a Car in Block Island

Unlike major tourist hubs, Block Island has limited but reliable car rental services. Most agencies operate right near the ferry landing or within walking distance of Old Harbor.

Here’s what you need to know:

• Downtown Rentals: The majority of car rental locations are near Old Harbor, which is where most ferries dock. It’s common for travelers to pick up their rental right after stepping off the ferry.
• Cruise/Ferry Terminal Services: Some companies offer vehicle pickup directly at the ferry terminal. Always confirm this when booking in advance.
• National Brands: You won’t find large chains like Hertz, Budget, or Avis on the island. Most rentals are run by local businesses, which provide a more personalized but limited fleet.
• Operating Hours: Many rental shops open from around 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM, but hours may be shorter in the off-season. It’s best to check and reserve ahead of time—especially during summer weekends.

Compare rental options here to check availability for your travel dates and vehicle preferences.

---

Recommended Car Rental Companies in Block Island

Here are a few well-known rental providers on the island:

• Block Island Bike & Car Rental
  Offers a variety of vehicles, from standard cars to Jeeps. They’re located directly across from the ferry terminal, making pickup and drop-off simple.
  Pros: Excellent location, friendly service.
  Cons: Small fleet—vehicles can sell out quickly in summer.
• Aldo’s Mopeds and Car Rentals
  Known more for scooters and mopeds, but they also have cars available.
  Pros: Good for last-minute rentals.
  Cons: Smaller vehicle selection.
• Payne’s Dock Car Rentals
  Located on the west side of the island, closer to New Harbor. Better suited for those staying in that area.
  Pros: Convenient for New Harbor visitors.
  Cons: Less central than Old Harbor options.

Tip: Compare car rental prices and book early here to secure a vehicle during busy travel periods.

---

How Much Does It Cost to Rent a Car in Block Island?

Rental prices on Block Island vary based on the season, the vehicle type, and rental duration. Here’s a general breakdown:

• Summer (June–August): $85–$130 per day for a standard vehicle.
• Spring/Fall Shoulder Seasons: $60–$100 per day.
• Off-Season (late fall to early spring): Some agencies close; others may offer lower rates.

Other factors that influence pricing include:

• Insurance coverage: May be offered for an additional daily fee.
• Mileage limits: Some rentals may include unlimited mileage; always check the terms.
• One-way rentals: Usually not applicable since the island is small and rentals are returned to the same office.

Check live prices here for the latest rates and availability based on your travel dates.

---

Requirements for Renting a Car in Block Island

Before you rent, make sure you meet the following:

• Minimum Age: Most rental agencies require drivers to be at least 21. Some may charge a surcharge for drivers under 25.
• Driver’s License: A valid U.S. or international driver’s license is required. Ensure it’s not expired.
• Credit or Debit Card: Most companies prefer credit cards for the security deposit, but some may accept debit cards. Always confirm their payment policy.
• Insurance: Basic insurance may be included, but you can typically purchase additional coverage. If you’re already covered through your credit card or personal auto insurance, bring documentation just in case.

---

Best Time to Rent a Car in Block Island

Block Island is a seasonal destination, and rental demand changes accordingly:

• Peak Season (June–August): Rentals are in high demand. It’s strongly recommended to book your vehicle several weeks in advance.
• Shoulder Seasons (May & September): More availability and slightly lower prices. Ideal for those who want to avoid summer crowds.
• Off-Season (October–April): Many businesses, including rental agencies, either close or operate with reduced hours. Availability may be limited.

Tip: Booking early is key during the summer months, especially for weekend stays and holidays.

---

Driving Tips in Block Island and Surroundings

Driving in Block Island is generally relaxed and stress-free, especially compared to mainland urban areas. However, there are still a few things to keep in mind:

• Road Conditions: Most roads on Block Island are paved, but some secondary roads can be narrow, uneven, or gravel-based—particularly those leading to more remote beaches or bluffs. Drive slowly and stay alert, especially near curves and hills.
• Wildlife Awareness: While you won’t encounter moose here, deer are common on the island, especially around wooded areas during dawn and dusk. Always drive cautiously at these times.
• Fuel Stations: There are limited gas stations on Block Island, and hours can vary. It’s wise to check fuel levels before exploring the island or confirm with your rental agency whether the car comes with a full tank.
• Parking Tips:
  • Free public parking is available at many beaches and scenic areas.
  • In downtown areas like Old Harbor, parking may be more limited during peak season. Respect posted signs and private property rules.
  • Some rental agencies may offer designated return parking—ask when you pick up the vehicle.

For the most up-to-date information on road conditions, consider checking Block Island’s official visitor site or local Department of Transportation resources.

---

Alternatives to Renting a Car in Block Island

Depending on your itinerary and length of stay, a rental car might not be necessary. Consider the following alternatives:

• Taxi Services: A few local taxi companies operate on the island, typically available near ferry landings. These are useful for quick, one-way trips.
• Bike Rentals: Biking is a popular option, especially in late spring through early fall. Rental shops like Island Bike & Moped offer hourly or daily rates.
• Mopeds: Easier to park than cars and faster than bikes, mopeds can be fun for confident drivers—but not ideal for gravel roads or rainy conditions.
• Walking: If you’re staying near Old Harbor and don’t plan to leave town, walking may be all you need.
• Shuttle Options: Some inns and B&Bs offer complimentary shuttles to and from the ferry or major sights.

If your plans mostly involve relaxing in town or taking guided tours, you might skip the rental car altogether.

---

Best Road Trips from Block Island

While Block Island itself doesn’t offer long-distance road trips due to its size, here are a few scenic mini-drives worth your time:

• Old Harbor to Mohegan Bluffs: A short drive south to dramatic cliffs and ocean views.
• Rodman’s Hollow Loop: Explore this conservation area and nearby coastal trails.
• North Lighthouse: A longer drive to the island’s northern tip, offering peaceful scenery and wildlife spotting.
• Settlers’ Rock and Coast Guard Station Beach: Quiet areas ideal for a peaceful afternoon drive and beach walk.

All of these routes take under 30 minutes each, but they’re perfect for seeing the island’s different sides in comfort.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a car for a day trip to Block Island?

Not necessarily. If you’re sticking to the main town and nearby attractions, walking, biking, or taking a taxi may be sufficient. However, for full-day access to distant sights like Mohegan Bluffs or North Lighthouse, a rental car adds convenience and flexibility.

Are there car rentals available directly at the ferry terminal?

Yes, several rental providers are located just steps from the Old Harbor ferry terminal. Be sure to reserve in advance, especially during summer, as walk-up availability can be limited.

Is parking free on Block Island?

Most parking, including at beaches and attractions, is free. However, spots may be limited in peak season, especially in Old Harbor. Always follow posted signs to avoid fines or towing.

Are SUVs or Jeeps necessary for Block Island roads?

Not usually. While some unpaved roads exist, most areas are accessible with a compact or midsize vehicle. A Jeep may be more comfortable for gravel routes, but it’s not essential.

Can I rent a car for just a few hours?

Yes, some agencies offer hourly rentals. This is a good option if you’re only planning to visit one or two locations outside of town.

Do car rentals on Block Island include insurance?

Basic liability insurance may be included, but coverage varies. Always ask the rental agency or use your credit card benefits or personal auto policy if applicable. Additional coverage may be available at the counter.

What’s the age requirement for renting a car?

Most rental agencies require drivers to be at least 21 years old. Some may apply a surcharge for drivers under 25. Always bring a valid license and credit card.

Are there electric vehicle rentals on Block Island?

At this time, electric vehicle rentals are not commonly offered on Block Island. Most fleets consist of gas-powered vehicles.

Can I return my rental after hours?

Some agencies allow after-hours drop-off with prior arrangement. Be sure to ask about return instructions when picking up your car.

How far in advance should I book a car rental?

In peak season (June–August), it’s best to book several weeks in advance. Last-minute availability is limited, and prices can increase closer to your travel dates.

---

Final Tips Before You Book

• Book Early: Summer dates and weekends sell out fast. Advance booking helps you lock in better rates and vehicle selection.
• Inspect the Vehicle: Walk around the car before driving off and note any existing damage. Take photos if needed.
• Review the Rental Terms: Understand mileage limits, fuel policies, cancellation rules, and insurance details before signing.

Ready to explore Block Island? Compare trusted car rental options here and plan your trip with confidence.